Search
Cahill header hands New York a winCahill header hands New York a win Toddler stars for ChelseaToddler stars for Chelsea Adam Gilchrist bowls, takes wicketAdam Gilchrist bowls, takes wicket
advertisement
Most popular articles
MMA KanvasAll the 'in your face' action from the MMA
Wide World of Sports TV partners
AFL Footy ShowAustralia's favourite team takes you through the week in AFL.NRL Footy ShowFatty and the gang bring you an entertaining look at rugby league.Footy ClassifiedOur award winning panel tell it how it really is in the AFL world.Wide World of SportsCatch up with Ken Sutcliffe and the team on Wide World of Sports.
Pumas' power could rattle Wallabies
Tim Sheridan
13:00 AEST Thu Sep 13 2012

Tim Sheridan is a reporter with Wide World of Sports and an integral member of the National Nine News team.
Tim Sheridan
  Have your say on the Wallabies

Diplomacy took a shove from the Argentinian Ambassador this week.

His Excellency Mr Pedro Villagra Delgado was hosting a cocktail party in honour of the Pumas' arrival in the Rugby Championship. The Ambassador's message is that his country won't miss this opportunity, and that its entry into the southern hemisphere's elite rugby competition augurs economic and sporting achievements.

That means beating the Wallabies.

It may not happen at Skilled Stadium on the Gold Coast this Saturday night, but the return match in Rosario on October 7 will give the Pumas an enormous opportunity to claim a big scalp.

As one rugby pundit put it, the Argentinians are like the Italians but they play that style of game a whole lot better.

The first tactic is to bloody the opposition's nose with a stampede off the defensive line – hundreds of kilos of power on the hoof. It tramples through the breakdown and often has halfbacks and fly-halves folding around each other to reset the play. The Springboks tried to counter and go through the Pumas but failed.

Then a mirage is set up. Show the opposition a whole load of sideline and wait for them to try for it. False width is an Argentine speciality and trying to get around them proved very difficult for the All Blacks. Rugby's best outside backs never really opened Argentina up.

At the Argentine function in Sydney, former Puma and Wallaby Enrique "Topo" Rodriguez spoke as a cross-cultural ambassador. One of the world's finest-ever front rowers pointed out there are now 100,000 registered rugby players in Argentina. He denies most of them are props.

The Pumas will be strong and ruthless at the set-piece this weekend, so stand-in Wallabies half Nick Phipps must aim his box kicks perfectly to turn the Puma behemoths around. Artless kicking has been the favourite spleen venting subject of all Wallabies fans this spring, but when asked how we get on the other side of the defence most critics are a bit more circumspect.

At rugby's highest level the advantage line is so close and defensive lines are now like cliff faces, so playing this type of game is almost the easier option. Let the attack punch itself out and, bereft of ideas, they will kick. With Kurtley Beale out of form, James O'Connor injured and Quade Cooper still finding his way back, the Wallabies are almost forced into this type of game.

Wallabies great Mark Ella pointed out recently how he often played attacking rugby behind beaten packs. He certainly did, and he was sublime, but I would ask how many of the opposition forwards were almost always defending three or four wide of the breakdown.

Rules in those days dictated most of the forwards be where they belonged – in the ruck or maul. Modern rugby's great dilemma is how to solve its ugly spectacle: two lines of players a few metres apart, right across the field, forwards grinding away like badgers until a penalty is given. A penalty no-one can understand.

The wider game's look and direction is hardly the Wallabies' problem this Saturday night, but then in a way it will be. The Pumas will exploit all the modern rules to squeeze some poor choices out of Australia.

Hopefully none of them will be kicks to nowhere.

Will the Pumas beat the Wallabies in their first Rugby Championship clash?
What do you think of the Wallabies tactics so far this spring?
Should the rules of rugby change to reduce the amount of kicking?

User comments
Firstly I think it is fantastic that the Pumas are now in a first competition like the The Championship. The disappointing aspect is that most of the population of Australia will not get to see the game on FTA as it is being played at a significant delay by Channel 9 (midnight in Victoria). As the broadcast partner for Australian Rugby it is a bitterly disappointing state of affairs. Please Channel 9 give the loyal Rugby fans of Australia a real reason that you will not play the games live on one of your channels.
I agree wholeheartedly with the suggestion that one of rugby's greatest dilemmas is to resolve the issue of 2 teams spreading themselves out across the field gravely limiting attacking opportunities resulting in endless ruck after ruck until a penalty ensues in relation to a certain rule that even an almost forty year follower of the code like me can't fully understand. Lets open up a serious debate about rule changes that encourage the forgotten joyous free flowing rugby spectacle? For a start, if the forwards are not going to be forced to committ to the ruck and maul, why not the backs (excluding the half) be required to stand 5 metres behind the advantage line?


You need the latest version of Flash Player.
Enjoy the most vivid content on the web
Watch video without extra features
Interact with applications on your favourite sites
Upgrade now