Search
Dream team keeps Pies' dream alive
Tony Jones
14:30 AEST Tue Jul 28 2009

Tony Jones is the face of Melbourne sports reporting for Channel Nine.
Tony Jones
  Have your say on the Malthouse-Buckley team.

Had he not decided on a career in television or a presidential role at Australia's most famous sporting club (Collingwood), Eddie McGuire might have been snapped up by the United Nations to try to settle the differences in the Middle East.

Yet again, he's proven himself as the master deal maker.

Who else could bring together Mick Malthouse and Nathan Buckley to form, arguably, the AFL's ultimate dream-team?

As other clubs were trying to satisfy Buckley's growing hunger for a senior coaching role, the Magpies were offering him what amounted to entree. An assistant coach's role.

Incredibly, Buckley agreed.

So, here's the deal.

Collingwood has signed both Malthouse and Buckley to five year agreements, with Malthouse handing over the senior coaching job at the end of 2011 and then spending the next three years in the newly created role of Director of Coaching.

Now that all sounds great in theory, but how will it work in reality?

Malthouse himself says there'll be sceptics who don't think the partnership is workable and, in truth, it'll only take a lean patch by Collingwood over the next couple of years for the media and members to be calling for a change of power immediately.

McGuire has pre-empted such talk with a simple 'mick malthouse is the senior coach for the next two years'.

By the time that two year period expires, Malthouse will have chalked up 40 years as both a player and coach at league level.

It's an extrodinary effort in modern sport and by the time his body clock ticks over to 60 years of age, this enigma of a man will be wanting to wind down.

Even more extraodinary is the fact that Malthouse has managed to squeeze another couple of years out of a club who knows only too well he hasn't delivered it a premiership in that decade.

The dream, of course, would be to hand the baton to Buckley after taking the Magpies to a flag or two before his time is up.

Then again, Collingwood is big on dreams and not all of them come true.

For McGuire though this is one which has.

Malthouse and Buckley. A dream-team in anyone's language.

Now Ed, what are you going to do about the Middle East?

Has Collingwood secured the AFL's dream team?
Can the partnership work?
Will Malthouse see out his remaining years as senior coach?

SHARE:
MESSENGER
FACEBOOK
MORE
Blog on Spaces
Add to delicious
Add to Digg
Share on MySpace
?
Share, bookmark, and save your favourite ninemsn articles and features.  Learn more.
User comments
Lets just wait & see if this works - I personally think Malthouse is past his use by date, he hasn't got a premiership for Collingwood yet in all the years he has been there. Malthouse may have had the pies up in the finals over the years but they still always get those good old "Colliwobbles" - Leigh Matthews was the only one who could break the Collingwood premiership drought. I guess we'll just have to see what happens with Bucks there. Personally I can't see Malthouse getting a premiership this year, once again his boys will fail so perhaps with Bucks help he finally notch a premiership on the board next year before he retires? Who knows, just because you were a great player doesn't necessarily mean you make a great coach so Buckley's got a lot to prove & pity help him if he doesn't get sooky Eddie what he wants.....
give buckley ago, yes some people think he will fail yet some dont. its worth watching what will happen right?? if all esle fails- then thats the time to argue and hang crap on him.. he might do alright considering people will have a positive feeling since he has been playing ledgondary footy for years, played in grand finals and been a great team leader in the past. although he might have been a great player does that really mean that the footy skill could convert to coachin skills??
It will be great if it all pans out, and I really hope it does. They will be a good combination with the teacher and the tutor, good on you magpie boys.
You're dreamin' Shoegirl. Nothing will change. They've managed 1 premiership since color TV was introduced. To see most of their premierships you would need to hire a movie theatre and hope the Movietone News reels haven't disintegrated over the decades!
How hypocritical would it be to stand in front of a team of players and insist that they play as a group and work hard for each other through thick and thin and yet not be able or willing to do the same with your own coaching panel and club management and committee members yourself? For all you critics Eddie is a smart man but has little footy knowledge when it comes to coaching but has realized that his staff needs to work as a group and he is leading with example, I take my hat of to the great man for what he is trying to do and can only see success once it is implemented correctly. Our biggest threat is the Iron fit the AFL will impose on the club to keep the contest even by way of draft picks and bands favoring the other clubs. Andrew needs to take a long look at this before he falls on the same sword in denying there are major problems with the way the draft and other issues work.
Voss won 3 premierships as capt, Buckly lost 2. Thats the difference. If was assitant in a premiership or played in one he would be ok but he hasnt. Full stop i cant wait to see him fail.
Yet again, he's proven himself as the master deal maker? Name another one? What, the hotel investment deal, or Tipstar, at Nine Eddie proved to be an Un-deal maker, costing Ch9 millions in payouts. Seems to me Eddie goes around costing his companies millions of dollars in payouts or losses. Now he throws $450,000 at Buckley because he loves him and cant stand not to have him. Jobs for the boys? No matter how many mistake's Eddie makes or how many people he alienates and bullies you still think he is a visionary. There is no substance to this announcement, Bucks is untried and Malthouse wont ever be a director of coaching because there is no such thing. Voss is a born leader, Buckley is a born perfectionist, there is a massive difference.
Then will prove itself when the Premiership Cup has Collingwood Premiers 2010 or and 2011 or and 2012 or and etc etc
Speaking from a coach’s point of view I can honestly say that the more help you can get the merrier but it’s hard to fine good help and when it is looking you in the face grab it with both hands. It would take a brave person to challenge this argument and someone with too much pride to ignore it. Having to much pride will hurt you in the way it can restrict or defend of others from getting involved with you. But someone is always going to become responsible for things that don’t work out so well because this is human nature and behavior of the media and paying members. Being answerable to someone is a healthy structure but to use an axe like approach as other clubs show considerable flair for is no way to solve your problems but by getting in to help rectifying them is how you seem to do your best. Winning a flag is getting harder to do with so many other clubs competing for it so we need to improve how we play on and of the field and teaching is just the beginning of your preparation.
For the critics of the new look collingwood coaching set up, Michael Voss was out and about, signed for a cadet stint with the eagles, and the minute his old coach vacated at the lions, Vossy left Whoosha and jumped right into the big gig at his old club where he was a star. Does anybody really blame Bucks for taking a secure option with a club he loved and served so well, as opposed to North or the Tiges. Mick is a great coach, but he is now over 60 years old, and in two years he may well prefer a more relaxed position. Seems like a good outcome for all. Go Pies, well done Gary, Eddie and the board, or was it just Ed.

Wallabies' shock loss to Scotland Scottish side beats the Wallabies for the first time in 27 years. ... read more. Mariners show no mercy to Fury The Central Coast Mariners have demolished North Queensland Fury. ... read more Meares wins two more golds Three wins for Anna Meares caps Australia's dominant World Cup. ... read more Playing for my people: Preston Preston Campbell will be bursting with pride as he captains the Indigenous All Stars. ... read more. Who owns this famous mo? Take a look through some of the world's most famous sporting mos
... view gallery.
Harden up softees Cricketers spend too much time in the gym and at the physio, writes Steve Hitstirrer ...read more. Crashing out Champion V8 driver Greg Murphy will be on the lookout for another team next year ... read more. Front foot Cricket Australia is on the hunt for more pace bowlers to push for a baggy green. ... read more Sports pics of the week WWOS delivers the best sports photography from around the globe
...view gallery.
advertisement
Most popular articles
Premier LeagueTeam by team guide to the 2009/10 season.
Also on WWOS
Footy tipping$5,000 in cash to be won. A-League and EPL tipping now open!Winter chillWarm up for all the Vancouver action in our new winter section.Photo galleriesThe best photography from across the Wide World of Sport.Sports videosCatch up with video coverage of your favourite sport.

You need the latest version of Flash Player.
Enjoy the most vivid content on the web
Watch video without extra features
Interact with applications on your favourite sites
Upgrade now
Other ninemsn businesses: iSelect RateCity
© 1997-2009 ninemsn Pty Ltd - All rights reserved